The Best Xbox Series X & S Controllers
We reviewed eight Xbox controllers for Series X and S, based on expert reviews, owner ratings, and discussion threads. The Carbon Black model offers the best balance of comfort, functionality, and price.
Updated
The bottom line
The XBOX Wireless Gaming Controller in Carbon Black (B0F1HX3WXX) is our top pick for Xbox Series X and S gamers. It provides a comfortable design, reliable performance, and versatile connectivity at $49.49. The closest alternative is the Xbox Wireless Controller (B0DT52LVMS) at $54.99, which has slightly higher owner ratings but lacks the same level of positive feedback on build quality. For those on a budget, the Robot White model (B0F1HTGDTL) at $48.99 is a good option, though it has reports of stick drift and inconsistent button quality.
XBOX Wireless Gaming Controller $49.49
Best balance of comfort and price
The Carbon Black model provides a modernized design, precise performance, and versatile connectivity for $49.49. Owners praise its build quality and comfort, though some note minor cosmetic wear. Skip it if you need accessories connectivity.
Check price on Amazon
Xbox Wireless Controller $54.99
Slightly higher-rated, slightly higher price
The Xbox Wireless Controller has a slightly higher owner rating and offers similar features for $54.99. It's a good choice if you can afford the extra $5 and want a slightly higher-rated option.
Check price on Amazon
XBOX Wireless Gaming Controller $48.99
Affordable with minor compromises
The Robot White model is the cheapest at $48.99 but has reports of stick drift and inconsistent button quality. It's a good option if you're on a tight budget and can tolerate these issues.
Check price on AmazonThe field, ranked
- XBOX Wireless Gaming Controller Best balance of comfort, functionality, and price 9.0/10 $49.49 Amazon
- Xbox Wireless Controller Highly rated but slightly more expensive 8.5/10 $54.99 Amazon
- XBOX Wireless Gaming Controller Affordable but with some quality issues 8.0/10 $48.99 Amazon
- XBOX Wireless Gaming Controller Versatile and comfortable but lacks accessories connectivity 8.0/10 $59.99 Amazon
- XBOX Wireless Gaming Controller Ergonomic and responsive but slightly more expensive 8.0/10 $55.99 Amazon
- Xbox Wireless Gaming Controller Vibrant design and extended battery life but pricey 8.0/10 $53.97 Amazon
- Xbox Wireless Gaming Controller Unique design and extended battery life but very expensive 7.5/10 $74.99 Amazon
- Xbox Wireless Controller Fallout Pip-Boy Themed design and extended battery life but overpriced 7.0/10 $99.99 Amazon
Where the differences show up in daily use
The Carbon Black model (B0F1HX3WXX) offers the best balance of comfort, build quality, and price. Owners frequently mention its solid construction and reliable performance. The Xbox Wireless Controller (B0DT52LVMS) offers similar features but at a slightly higher price. The Robot White model (B0F1HTGDTL) is the most affordable but has reports of stick drift and inconsistent button quality.
Who should buy which
Gamers looking for the best balance of comfort and price should choose the Carbon Black model (B0F1HX3WXX). Those willing to spend a bit more for a slightly higher-rated option should consider the Xbox Wireless Controller (B0DT52LVMS). Budget-conscious gamers should opt for the Robot White model (B0F1HTGDTL), despite its minor quality issues.
What owners complain about after buying
Owners of the Robot White model (B0F1HTGDTL) have reported stick drift and inconsistent button quality. Some users of the Carbon Black model (B0F1HX3WXX) have noted minor cosmetic wear. The Xbox Wireless Controller (B0DT52LVMS) has received positive feedback overall, with only minor complaints about stick drift in a few cases.
The also-rans
The Shock Blue (B0F1J12R6N), Pulse Red (B0F1HDBJKH), Heart Breaker Special Edition (B0FLLL1ZD8), and Forza Horizon 6 Limited Edition (B0GS3Z1X2Q) models all offer similar features but at higher prices or with minor compromises. The Fallout Pip-Boy (B0FTQ5RJM7) is a themed controller with a unique design but is significantly more expensive.