The Best Vitamin D3 Supplements
We compared 7 top-rated Vitamin D3 supplements on owner ratings, expert reviews, and price. Nature Made Vitamin D3 (B004U3Y8OM) is our top pick.
Updated
The bottom line
Nature Made Vitamin D3 (B004U3Y8OM) is our top pick for its high owner rating of 4.8 from 61,348 reviews, affordability at $8.09, and USP verification. NatureWise Vitamin D3 5000IU (B00GB85JR4) is a close runner-up with a 4.8 rating from 158,706 owners and NSF certification, but at $14.99 it costs more. For a budget option, NatureWise Vitamin D3 1000IU (B0CKFX6YVR) has a 4.7 rating from 9,164 owners at $10.19. Skip NatureWise Vitamin D3 10000IU (B0DPNNFXZS) unless you need the extra strength, as it has fewer reviews and a higher price.
Nature Made Vitamin D3 $8.09
Best balance of price, ratings, and verification
Nature Made Vitamin D3 has a 4.8 owner rating from 61,348 reviews, USP verification, and a price of $8.09. It's gluten-free and recommended by pharmacists. The tradeoff is a lower dosage of 1000 IU compared to some alternatives.
Check price on Amazon
NatureWise Vitamin D3 $14.99
Highest-rated with NSF certification
NatureWise Vitamin D3 5000IU has a 4.8 owner rating from 158,706 reviews and NSF certification. At $14.99, it's more expensive but has a higher dosage of 5000 IU. Consider this if you need a stronger dose.
Check price on Amazon
NatureWise Vitamin D3 $10.19
Affordable with strong owner ratings
NatureWise Vitamin D3 1000IU has a 4.7 owner rating from 9,164 reviews at $10.19. It's a good option if you're on a budget and don't need the higher dosages.
Check price on AmazonThe field, ranked
- Nature Made Vitamin D3 Best balance of price, ratings, and verification 9.5/10 $8.09 Amazon
- NatureWise Vitamin D3 Highest-rated with NSF certification 9.3/10 $14.99 Amazon
- NatureWise Vitamin D3 Affordable with strong owner ratings 9.2/10 $10.19 Amazon
- NatureWise Vitamin D3 4000IU Supplement Good value for the price 9.1/10 $5.09 Amazon
- NatureWise Vitamin D3 10000IU Supplement High dosage but fewer reviews 8.9/10 $14.99 Amazon
- NatureWise Vitamin D3 Strong owner ratings but mid-range price 8.8/10 $7.64 Amazon
- Nature Made Vit D-3 1000Iu High owner ratings but higher price 8.7/10 $18.49 Amazon
Where the differences show up in daily use
Owners of Nature Made Vitamin D3 (B004U3Y8OM) and NatureWise Vitamin D3 5000IU (B00GB85JR4) frequently mention the ease of swallowing the softgels and the convenience of the dosage. NatureWise Vitamin D3 1000IU (B0CKFX6YVR) owners appreciate the smaller size and ease of use, while some note issues with melting during hot weather.
What owners complain about after buying
A few owners of NatureWise Vitamin D3 1000IU (B0CKFX6YVR) reported issues with the softgels melting during hot weather, which could be a concern for those living in warmer climates. NatureWise Vitamin D3 4000IU (B0CKFMCLFP) had some reports of softgels sticking together, though this was easily resolved with a bit of powdered sugar.
The also-rans
NatureWise Vitamin D3 4000IU (B0CKFMCLFP) and NatureWise Vitamin D3 10000IU (B0DPNNFXZS) did not earn picks due to fewer owner reviews and higher prices compared to the top picks. NatureWise Vitamin D3 (B0CKFQVNDL) is a solid option but doesn't offer significant advantages over the top picks to warrant a specific role.