The Best Toothpastes
We compared eight toothpastes on owner ratings, expert reviews, and specs. Boka Toothpaste (asin B0FP2JFHBS) is our top pick for its effectiveness and gentle formulation.
Updated
The bottom line
Boka Toothpaste (asin B0FP2JFHBS) is our top pick, scoring high on owner ratings with a 4.5/5 rating from 62,621 owners. It offers a fluoride-free formula with Nano-hydroxyapatite for enamel care, priced at $8.22. The closest alternative is Colgate Optic White (asin B082F1QH7S), which provides strong whitening properties but at a slightly higher price of $8.54. For a budget option, Boka Toothpaste (asin B0FP2KCQH3) at $7.99 offers similar benefits with a 4.5/5 rating from 61,623 owners. Those seeking fluoride-based whitening should consider Colgate Optic White, while Boka options are better for those avoiding fluoride.
Boka Toothpaste $8.22
Best balance of effectiveness and gentleness
Boka Toothpaste (asin B0FP2JFHBS) has a fluoride-free formula with Nano-hydroxyapatite, which owners rate 4.5/5 from 62,621 ratings. Priced at $8.22, it offers a refreshing mint flavor and low-foaming texture. The tradeoff is its higher price compared to conventional toothpastes.
Check price on Amazon
Colgate Optic White $8.54
Strong whitening with enamel safety
Colgate Optic White (asin B082F1QH7S) has a 4.7/5 rating from 51,739 owners. It contains 2% hydrogen peroxide for whitening and is safe for enamel. Priced at $8.54, it offers noticeable whitening effects. The tradeoff is potential sensitivity for some users.
Check price on Amazon
Boka Toothpaste - Fluoride Free Toothpaste, Nano Hydroxyapatite Toothpaste $7.99
Affordable fluoride-free option
Boka Toothpaste (asin B0FP2KCQH3) is a budget-friendly option at $7.99 with a 4.5/5 rating from 61,623 owners. It contains Nano-hydroxyapatite and is free from fluoride, peroxide, sulfates, parabens, and artificial colors. The tradeoff is minor tooth sensitivity issues for some users.
Check price on AmazonThe field, ranked
- Boka Toothpaste Best for gentle, effective cleaning 9.0/10 $8.22 Amazon
- Colgate Optic White Best for strong whitening 8.5/10 $8.54 Amazon
- Boka Toothpaste - Fluoride Free Toothpaste, Nano Hydroxyapatite Toothpaste Best budget option 8.0/10 $7.99 Amazon
- Boka Toothpaste Good for fluoride-free, lemon flavor 7.5/10 $31.99 Amazon
- Boka Toothpaste Good for sensitive teeth, mint flavor 7.0/10 $9.99 Amazon
- Boka Toothpaste Good for minty fresh feel 6.5/10 $11.62 Amazon
- Boka Toothpaste Mixed reviews on cavity formation 6.0/10 $9.30 Amazon
- Boka Ela Mint Whitening Sensitive Toothpaste Limited evidence, high price 5.0/10 $34.82 Amazon
Who should buy which
Those avoiding fluoride should opt for Boka Toothpaste (asin B0FP2JFHBS) or Boka Toothpaste (asin B0FP2KCQH3). For strong whitening, Colgate Optic White (asin B082F1QH7S) is the best choice despite its higher price. Sensitive teeth users may prefer Boka Toothpaste (asin B0DJTT6B8P) for its gentle formula.
Owner complaints
Some owners report increased cavity formation and rough spots on teeth with Boka Toothpaste (asin B0BSRFKKZJ). A few users of Boka Toothpaste (asin B0FP2JFHBS) and Boka Toothpaste (asin B0FP2KCQH3) mention minor tooth sensitivity issues. Colgate Optic White (asin B082F1QH7S) users report sensitivity, though it is generally well-tolerated.
Also-rans
Boka Toothpaste (asin B0GYFH57NY) has limited evidence and a high price, making it a less compelling option. Boka Toothpaste (asin B0BSRFKKZJ) has mixed reviews on cavity formation, which detracts from its overall score.