The Best Toilet Papers
We compared 8 top-rated toilet papers on owner ratings, expert reviews, and specs. Angel Soft Bulk Bathroom Tissue is our top pick for its softness, strength, and value.
Updated
The bottom line
Angel Soft Bulk Bathroom Tissue (asin B09NW9JQNC) is our top pick for its exceptional softness, strength, and value, backed by over 107,000 5-star ratings. If you prefer a luxurious feel, Quilted Northern Ultra Plush (asin B0854WL4G3) has a 3-ply construction with exceptional absorbency but at a higher price. For budget-conscious buyers, Scott ComfortPlus Toilet Paper (asin B07BGLT25K) offers good quality at an affordable price, though some users report it finishes quickly.
Angel Soft Toilet Paper $7.59
Best balance of softness, strength, and value
Angel Soft Bulk Bathroom Tissue offers 8 mega rolls for $7.59, equivalent to 32 regular rolls. It is highly rated for its softness, strength, and septic safety, with over 107,000 positive owner ratings. The tradeoff is minor issues with ordering and delivery reported by a few users.
Check price on Amazon
Quilted Northern Ultra Plush $33.32
Premium softness and absorbency
Quilted Northern Ultra Plush has a 3-ply construction with exceptional absorbency. Priced at $33.32 for 18 mega rolls, it is well-regarded for its softness and durability. The tradeoff is its higher price compared to other options.
Check price on Amazon
Scott ComfortPlus Toilet Paper $4.83
Affordable quality
Scott ComfortPlus Toilet Paper offers 12 triple rolls for $4.83, with over 134,000 positive owner ratings. It is praised for its softness and strength but some users report it finishes quickly. Best for those looking for a cost-effective option.
Check price on AmazonThe field, ranked
- Angel Soft Toilet Paper Best balance of softness, strength, and value 10.0/10 $7.59 Amazon
- Quilted Northern Ultra Plush Premium softness and absorbency at a higher price 9.0/10 $33.32 Amazon
- Scott ComfortPlus Toilet Paper Affordable quality with minor quantity concerns 8.0/10 $4.83 Amazon
- Angel Soft Toilet Paper Highly rated for softness and durability 8.0/10 $39.16 Amazon
- Angel Soft Toilet Paper Large, long-lasting rolls with high customer ratings 8.0/10 $8.96 Amazon
- Scott ComfortPlus Toilet Paper Good value with enhanced thickness and strength 7.0/10 $12.15 Amazon
- Scott ComfortPlus Toilet Paper Bulk pack with high customer satisfaction 7.0/10 $31.19 Amazon
- Scott ComfortPlus Scented Tube Toilet Paper Scented option with good softness and strength 6.0/10 $7.20 Amazon
Where the differences show up in daily use
Users of Angel Soft report it dissolves well and prevents clogs, making it a favorite for those with septic systems. Quilted Northern's 3-ply construction offers a plush, cushioned feel that reduces the need for excessive use. Scott ComfortPlus, while affordable, has received mixed feedback on its quantity, with some users reporting it finishes quickly.
Who should buy which
Angel Soft is best for those looking for a balance of softness, strength, and value. Quilted Northern is best for those who prioritize premium softness and absorbency. Scott ComfortPlus is a good choice for budget-conscious buyers who still want decent quality.
What owners complain about after buying
Some users of Scott ComfortPlus have reported issues with the quantity, noting that the rolls seem to finish quickly. A few users of Angel Soft have mentioned minor irritation or lint, though these complaints are rare.
The also-rans
Scott ComfortPlus Tube Toilet Paper (asin B0DKKPRGWL) and Scott ComfortPlus Toilet Paper (asin B0H3MD9HB1) are good options but don't offer the same balance of softness, strength, and value as Angel Soft. They are more suited for those who prefer scented options or specific bulk quantities.