The Best Throw Pillow Inserts
We reviewed eight Utopia Bedding pillow inserts, based on 1.75 million owner ratings and reviews. The 24x24 inch inserts are our top pick for their balance of comfort, structure, and price.
Updated
The bottom line
The Utopia Bedding 24x24 Pillow Inserts (asin B07XXT6LK2) are our top pick for throw pillow inserts. They have soft, durable brushed microfiber fabric and high-rebound filling that maintains shape, all at an affordable price of $16.57. The closest alternative is the 26x26 inch inserts (asin B07Y9QYW88) at $21.89, which provide similar comfort but at a slightly higher cost. For a budget option, the 18x18 inch inserts (asin B01NBNDC1T) at $16.19 offer good value but may require more fluffing to achieve optimal shape.
Utopia Bedding Pillow Inserts $16.57
Best balance of comfort and price
The 24x24 inch inserts have soft, durable fabric and maintain shape well at $16.57. Owners rate them 9.2/10 from 218,893 ratings. The tradeoff is the need for fluffing to achieve optimal shape.
Check price on Amazon
Utopia Bedding Pillow Inserts, White Throw Pillows $21.89
Excellent comfort at a slightly higher price
The 26x26 inch inserts provide similar comfort and durability at $21.89. Owners rate them 9.2/10 from 219,065 ratings. The tradeoff is the higher price compared to the top pick.
Check price on Amazon
Utopia Bedding Pillow Inserts $16.19
Affordable with good comfort
The 18x18 inch inserts have soft fabric and maintain shape at $16.19. Owners rate them 9.2/10 from 218,959 ratings. The tradeoff is the need for more fluffing to achieve optimal shape.
Check price on AmazonThe field, ranked
- Utopia Bedding Pillow Inserts Best balance of comfort, structure, and price. 9.0/10 $16.57 Amazon
- Utopia Bedding Pillow Inserts, White Throw Pillows Excellent comfort at a slightly higher price. 8.5/10 $21.89 Amazon
- Utopia Bedding Pillow Inserts Affordable with good comfort, needs more fluffing. 8.0/10 $16.19 Amazon
- Utopia Bedding Pillow Inserts Good comfort and durability, needs fluffing. 7.5/10 $18.89 Amazon
- Utopia Bedding Pillow Inserts Comfortable and supportive, needs fluffing. 7.0/10 $27.89 Amazon
- Utopia Bedding Pillow Inserts Durable and supportive, needs fluffing. 6.5/10 $28.49 Amazon
- Utopia Bedding Pillow Inserts Soft and supportive, needs fluffing. 6.0/10 $39.89 Amazon
- Utopia Bedding Pillow Inserts Fluffy and comfortable, needs fluffing. 5.5/10 $31.49 Amazon
Where the differences show up in daily use
Owners frequently mention the need to fluff these inserts to achieve optimal shape. The 24x24 and 26x26 inch inserts are easier to fluff and maintain their shape better than the smaller sizes. The 18x18 inch inserts require more fluffing but offer good value for the price.
Who should buy which
If you prioritize comfort and structure at an affordable price, go for the 24x24 inch inserts. If you can afford a bit more for slightly larger size and similar comfort, the 26x26 inch inserts are a good choice. For a budget-friendly option, the 18x18 inch inserts offer good value but may require more effort to fluff.
What owners complain about after buying
The most common complaint across all sizes is the need to fluff the inserts to achieve optimal shape. Some owners also mention that the inserts may appear flat initially and require drying to regain fluffiness after washing.
The also-rans
The 14x14, 14x22, 14x20, 28x28, and 22x22 inch inserts did not make the top picks due to either higher price, smaller size, or lower owner ratings. The 14x14 and 14x22 inch inserts are good for smaller decorative pillows, while the 28x28 and 22x22 inch inserts offer larger sizes but at a higher cost.