The Best Protein Shakes
We compared eight Premier Protein Shakes on taste, protein content, and owner satisfaction. The Premier Protein Shake (B00AAJRPZY) has the highest protein content and positive owner feedback.
Updated
The bottom line
The Premier Protein Shake (B00AAJRPZY) is our top pick for its high protein content (30g per shake), low sugar and fat, and positive customer feedback on taste and convenience. It's priced at $7.3 for a single shake, making it a cost-effective choice. The closest alternative is the Premier Protein +Energy Shake (B08NTY1787), which has similar protein content but includes caffeine. For those on a budget, the Premier Protein Shake (B00MH5GGFO) is slightly lower priced at $23.97 for a 4-pack, though some users report issues with taste and quality over time.
Premier Protein Shake $7.30
Best overall protein shake for taste and convenience
This shake has 30g of protein per serving, low sugar and fat, and has received high praise for its taste and convenience. Priced at $7.3, it's a cost-effective option. Those sensitive to caffeine should consider alternatives.
Check price on Amazon
Premier Protein Shake $8.59
Best protein shake with added caffeine
This shake has 30g of protein, 24 vitamins and minerals, and caffeine equivalent to 1 cup of coffee. It's priced at $8.59 and has received positive reviews for its taste and texture. Suitable for those needing an energy boost.
Check price on Amazon
Premier Protein Shake $23.97
Best budget protein shake
Offering 30g of protein per serving at $23.97 for a 4-pack, this shake is a cost-effective option. However, some users report issues with taste and quality over time. Suitable for those on a tight budget.
Check price on AmazonThe field, ranked
- Premier Protein Shake Best for taste, convenience, and protein content. 10.0/10 $7.30 Amazon
- Premier Protein Shake Best for those needing an energy boost with caffeine. 9.0/10 $8.59 Amazon
- Premier Protein Shake Best budget option with decent protein content. 8.0/10 $23.97 Amazon
- Premier Protein Shake Good protein content and low sugar, but less popular. 8.0/10 $8.59 Amazon
- Premier Protein Shake High protein content, but less flavor variety. 8.0/10 $9.19 Amazon
- Premier Protein Shake Good taste and protein content, but higher price. 7.0/10 $20.37 Amazon
- Premier Protein 30g High Protein Shake Cookies & Cream 4 Pack Decent protein content, but fewer positive reviews. 7.0/10 $8.58 Amazon
- Premier Protein Shake Unique flavor, but mixed reviews on taste and texture. 6.0/10 $7.30 Amazon
Who should buy which
Those looking for a high-protein, low-sugar shake with positive taste feedback should go for the Premier Protein Shake (B00AAJRPZY). If you need an energy boost, the Premier Protein +Energy Shake (B08NTY1787) is the way to go. Budget-conscious buyers should consider the Premier Protein Shake (B00MH5GGFO), though be aware of potential taste and quality issues.
What owners complain about
Some owners report a decline in taste and texture for the Premier Protein Shake (B00MH5GGFO) over time. There are also concerns about spoilage before the expiration date and blood sugar spikes for those with Type 1 Diabetes. The Cinnamon Roll flavor (B0DK7PY6XH) has mixed reviews on sweetness and texture.