Gist.product intelligenceBuying guides
Buying guide

The Best Mattress Encasements

We reviewed 8 mattress encasements, based on 1,068,865 owner ratings and reviews. The Utopia Bedding Queen Mattress Protector is our top pick.

Updated

The bottom line

The Utopia Bedding Queen Mattress Protector is our top pick for a mattress encasement. It offers 360° coverage, a secure zippered closure, and is made from soft, durable polyester fabric. It is highly rated by users for its effectiveness and comfort, with an average rating of 4.6/5 from 133,667 ratings. The closest alternative is the Utopia Bedding Full Mattress Protector, which offers similar features at a slightly lower price. For a budget option, the Utopia Bedding Crib Mattress Protector is a good choice, offering waterproof protection at an affordable price.

Top pick
Utopia Bedding Queen Mattress ProtectorUtopia Bedding Queen Mattress Protector $48.99

Best overall mattress encasement

The Utopia Bedding Queen Mattress Protector offers comprehensive protection, a secure fit, and is easy to maintain. It is priced at $48.99 and has an average rating of 4.6/5 from 133,667 ratings. The tradeoff is that the material may feel thinner than expected.

Check price on Amazon
Budget pick
Utopia Bedding Crib Mattress ProtectorUtopia Bedding Crib Mattress Protector $18.04

Affordable waterproof protection

The Utopia Bedding Crib Mattress Protector offers waterproof protection at an affordable price. It is priced at $18.04 and has an average rating of 4.6/5 from 133,939 ratings. The tradeoff is that it may be loose on thinner mattresses.

Check price on Amazon

The field, ranked

  1. Utopia Bedding Queen Mattress Protector Best overall protection and fit 9.0/10 $48.99 Amazon
  2. Utopia Bedding Crib Mattress Protector Affordable waterproof protection 8.0/10 $18.04 Amazon
  3. Utopia Bedding Mattress Protector Good protection and fit for full-sized mattresses 8.0/10 $47.99 Amazon
  4. Utopia Bedding Mattress Protector Soft and durable protection for twin XL mattresses 8.0/10 $41.99 Amazon
  5. Utopia Bedding Mattress Protector Affordable protection for king-sized mattresses 8.0/10 $32.99 Amazon
  6. Utopia Bedding Mattress Protector Effective protection for queen-sized mattresses 8.0/10 $22.04 Amazon
  7. Hotel California King Mattress Encasement Good protection for California king-sized mattresses 8.0/10 $32.99 Amazon
  8. Hotel Twin Size Mattress Encasement Expensive option with good protection 7.0/10 $228.99 Amazon

Where the differences show up in daily use

Users have reported that the Utopia Bedding Queen Mattress Protector completely encases the mattress and zips securely closed, providing peace of mind against spills and accidents. The soft and durable polyester fabric also adds comfort to the bed. On the other hand, some users have noted that the material may feel thinner than expected, but overall, it offers good value for the price.

What owners complain about after buying

A recurring complaint among owners is that the waterproof lining of the Utopia Bedding mattress protectors may disintegrate after multiple washes. This can make cleanup tedious and may require replacing the protector more frequently than expected. Additionally, some users have reported that the material may rip near the zipper during installation, which can be frustrating. However, these issues are relatively minor compared to the overall positive feedback and high customer satisfaction.

How this was put together

This buying guide is based on 1,068,865 owner ratings and reviews, 1 expert review, and 2 video reviews across the set of 8 mattress encasements. The evidence was carefully weighed, with a higher emphasis on owner ratings and reviews due to their larger sample size. No hands-on testing was conducted, and the evidence runs thin on the Hotel Twin Size Mattress Encasement due to its significantly higher price compared to the other options.