The Best Lycopene Supplements
We compared four lycopene supplements based on owner ratings, owner quotes, and price. Puritan's Pride Premium Lycopene 40mg emerged as the top pick for its high lycopene content and strong user satisfaction.
Updated
The bottom line
Puritan's Pride Premium Lycopene 40mg (B004R6942S) is our top pick for the best lycopene supplement. It offers 40mg of lycopene per softgel, significantly higher than the other options, and has a strong user satisfaction rating of 9/10 from 1923 ratings. The Puritan's Pride Premium Lycopene (B00WZJQCL0) is a budget-friendly alternative with 20mg per softgel and a similar high user satisfaction rating. VitaUp Lycopene Supplements for Men (B0CXF8Q2BQ) and NOW Supplements Lycopene with Extract from Tomatoes (B0013OXEYQ) are also strong contenders, offering 30mg and 20mg per softgel respectively, but at higher price points.
Puritan's Pride Premium Lycopene 40mg $15.25
High lycopene content and strong user satisfaction
Puritan's Pride Premium Lycopene 40mg offers 40mg of lycopene per softgel, the highest among the compared products, and has a user satisfaction rating of 9/10 from 1923 ratings. Priced at $15.25, it is a cost-effective option for those seeking a high-dose lycopene supplement. The tradeoff is the higher price compared to the 20mg version.
Check price on Amazon
Puritan's Pride Premium Lycopene $6.94
Affordable option with strong user satisfaction
Puritan's Pride Premium Lycopene offers 20mg of lycopene per softgel at a price of $6.94, making it the most affordable option. It has a user satisfaction rating of 9.2/10 from 2011 ratings, indicating strong user satisfaction. The tradeoff is the lower lycopene content compared to the 40mg version.
Check price on Amazon
VitaUp Lycopene Supplements for Men $26.91
Natural tomato extract with strong user satisfaction
VitaUp Lycopene Supplements for Men offers 30mg of lycopene per capsule, derived from natural tomato extract. It has a user satisfaction rating of 9.2/10 from 550 ratings. Priced at $26.91, it is a suitable choice for those looking for a natural, non-GMO, and gluten-free option. The tradeoff is the higher price.
Check price on Amazon
NOW Supplements Lycopene with Extract from Tomatoes $19.58
Tomato extract with strong user satisfaction
NOW Supplements Lycopene with Extract from Tomatoes offers 20mg of lycopene per softgel, derived from tomatoes. It has a user satisfaction rating of 9.2/10 from 627 ratings. Priced at $19.58, it is a good choice for those looking for a reputable brand with a history since 1968. The tradeoff is the lower lycopene content compared to the 40mg version.
Check price on AmazonThe field, ranked
- Puritan's Pride Premium Lycopene 40mg Best for high lycopene content and user satisfaction 9.0/10 $15.25 Amazon
- VitaUp Lycopene Supplements for Men Great for natural tomato extract and user satisfaction 8.0/10 $26.91 Amazon
- NOW Supplements Lycopene with Extract from Tomatoes Good for tomato extract and user satisfaction 8.0/10 $19.58 Amazon
- Puritan's Pride Premium Lycopene Budget-friendly with strong user satisfaction 7.0/10 $6.94 Amazon
Where the differences show up in daily use
Users of Puritan's Pride Premium Lycopene 40mg (B004R6942S) and VitaUp Lycopene Supplements for Men (B0CXF8Q2BQ) reported noticeable improvements in prostate health and skin maintenance, respectively. NOW Supplements Lycopene with Extract from Tomatoes (B0013OXEYQ) users noted some reduction in cholesterol levels but limited effect on blood pressure. Puritan's Pride Premium Lycopene (B00WZJQCL0) users appreciated the affordable price and strong user satisfaction.
What owners complain about after buying
Some users of VitaUp Lycopene Supplements for Men (B0CXF8Q2BQ) reported no significant reduction in PSA levels despite taking the supplement as directed. NOW Supplements Lycopene with Extract from Tomatoes (B0013OXEYQ) users also noted limited effectiveness on blood pressure. These complaints, however, were not widespread and did not significantly impact the overall user satisfaction ratings.