The Best Permanent Hair Dyes
We compared eight L'Oreal Paris Excellence Crème dyes on gray coverage, user satisfaction, and price. The B07D9SRNF4 shade 6A Light Ash Brown leads with consistent performance and high user ratings.
Updated
The bottom line
The L'Oreal Paris Excellence Crème shade 6A Light Ash Brown (asin B07D9SRNF4) is our top pick for permanent hair dye, thanks to its 9.2/10 owner rating from 64,099 reviews and consistent gray coverage. The closest alternative is the B07D9W595W shade 4RM Dark Mahogany Red, which also scores 9.4/10 but has fewer reviews. For budget shoppers, the B000GCSYC8 shade 5RB Medium Reddish Brown offers similar performance at $10.17.
L'Oreal Paris Excellence Crème $20.35
Best overall permanent hair dye
With a 9.2/10 rating from 64,099 owners, the B07D9SRNF4 shade 6A Light Ash Brown offers reliable gray coverage and a triple care routine. Priced at $20.35, it's a strong choice for most hair types. Those seeking a different shade might prefer the B07D9W595W.
Check price on Amazon
L'Oreal Paris Excellence Crème $23.98
Best alternative shade
The B07D9W595W shade 4RM Dark Mahogany Red scores 9.4/10 from 1,993 owners and offers similar benefits to the top pick. At $23.98, it's slightly more expensive but provides consistent quality and color coverage. Suitable for those who prefer a redder tone.
Check price on Amazon
L'Oreal Paris Excellence Crème $10.17
Best budget option
The B000GCSYC8 shade 5RB Medium Reddish Brown is the cheapest at $10.17, with a 9.4/10 rating from 2,019 owners. It offers effective gray coverage and a triple care routine, making it a good choice for budget-conscious buyers.
Check price on AmazonThe field, ranked
- L'Oreal Paris Excellence Crème Best for consistent gray coverage and high user satisfaction. 9.2/10 $20.35 Amazon
- L'Oreal Paris Excellence Crème Best alternative shade with consistent quality. 9.4/10 $23.98 Amazon
- L'Oreal Paris Excellence Crème Best budget option with effective gray coverage. 9.4/10 $10.17 Amazon
- L'Oreal Paris Excellence Crème Hair Dye Good gray coverage and user satisfaction. 9.0/10 $20.35 Amazon
- L'Oreal Paris Excellence Crème Effective gray coverage and triple care routine. 9.4/10 $23.94 Amazon
- L'Oreal Paris Excellence Crème Good gray coverage and user satisfaction. 9.2/10 $20.35 Amazon
- L'Oreal Paris Excellence Crème Good gray coverage and user satisfaction. 9.2/10 $11.97 Amazon
- L'Oreal Paris Excellence Crème Good gray coverage but may have color inconsistencies. 9.2/10 $23.94 Amazon
Where the differences show up
The main differences among these dyes lie in the shade and price. The B07D9SRNF4 and B07D9W595W offer similar performance but different shades, while the B000GCSYC8 provides a budget-friendly option with slightly fewer reviews.
Who should buy which
Those looking for the best overall performance should choose the B07D9SRNF4. Budget shoppers should consider the B000GCSYC8, and those wanting a different shade might prefer the B07D9W595W.
What owners complain about
Some owners of the B07D9SW78L reported color inconsistencies, and a few users of the B07D9W595W mentioned it didn't cover gray hair perfectly. However, these issues were not widespread.
The also-rans
The B07D9P7S14 and B07D9XZ1N3, while good, didn't stand out enough to earn a pick role. The B07D9TJMGT and B004C0NX8U are strong choices but were edged out by the top picks in terms of reviews and price.