The Best Fresh Onions
We compared 8 fresh onions on Amazon, based on 197,292 owner ratings and reviews. The Yellow Onion (B001W3T2SK) is our top pick for its high satisfaction and crisp texture.
Updated
The bottom line
The Yellow Onion (B001W3T2SK) is our top pick, scoring 9.4/10 from 50,554 owners. It has a firm texture and fresh flavor at $1.19. The closest alternative is the Organic Sweet Yellow Onion (B001GIP5G4), also scoring 9.4/10 but at a higher price of $33.99. For a budget option, the Green Onions (B002B9280S) score 9.2/10 from 24,974 owners at $1, though some owners note texture could be better.
Yellow Onion $1.19
Best overall fresh onion
The Yellow Onion (B001W3T2SK) scores 9.4/10 from 50,554 owners for its firm texture and fresh flavor. At $1.19, it's a great value. Skip if you need organic options.
Check price on Amazon
Organic Sweet Yellow Onion
Best organic option
The Organic Sweet Yellow Onion (B001GIP5G4) scores 9.4/10 from 18,882 owners for its vibrant color and flavor. At $33.99, it's pricier but has organic quality. Skip if budget is a concern.
Check price on Amazon
Green Onions $1.00
Best budget option
The Green Onions (B002B9280S) score 9.2/10 from 24,974 owners for their versatility and freshness. At $1, they're the cheapest option. Skip if you need larger onions.
Check price on AmazonThe field, ranked
- Yellow Onion Best for flavor and texture, skip for organic needs 9.4/10 $1.19 Amazon
- Organic Sweet Yellow Onion Best organic option, skip for budget constraints 9.4/10 Amazon
- Green Onions Best budget option, skip for larger onion needs 9.2/10 $1.00 Amazon
- Red Onion Great organic red onion, skip for yellow onion preference 9.4/10 $2.98 Amazon
- Red Onions Good red onion bag, skip for individual onion preference 9.4/10 $15.99 Amazon
- Yellow Onions Good yellow onion bag, skip for individual onion preference 9.4/10 Amazon
- Red Onion Great red onion, skip for yellow onion preference 9.4/10 $33.99 Amazon
- Organic Yellow Onion Good organic yellow onion, skip for non-organic needs 9.4/10 $33.99 Amazon
Who should buy which
If you prioritize flavor and texture, the Yellow Onion (B001W3T2SK) is your best bet. For those who need organic options, the Organic Sweet Yellow Onion (B001GIP5G4) is the way to go, despite its higher price. Budget-conscious buyers should opt for the Green Onions (B002B9280S), which offer great value at $1.
What owners complain about
Some owners of the Green Onions (B002B9280S) mention that the texture could be better, with some noting limpness upon arrival. This is a minor issue for most, but something to consider if texture is crucial for your recipes.
The also-rans
The Red Onion (B000P6L436) and the Organic Yellow Onion (B001GIP2BM) both score highly but don't offer significant advantages over the top picks. The Red Onions (B08TP7FCFW) and Yellow Onions (B08TP8PQTB) in bag form are convenient but don't offer the same individual onion quality as the top picks.