The Best Dog Calming Supplements
We compared five dog calming supplements on owner ratings, reviews, and prices. WOOF Pupsicle Refill Pops for Calming is our top pick for its effectiveness and affordability.
Updated
The bottom line
WOOF Pupsicle Refill Pops for Calming is our top pick due to its high owner satisfaction, long-lasting calming effect, and affordable price. Zesty Paws Calming Chews are a close runner-up, providing similar benefits at a slightly higher cost. Pro Plan Calming Care is a more expensive option with mixed results, making it less attractive for budget-conscious buyers. Zesty Paws Vet Strength Calming Chews, despite being the most expensive, lack significant advantages over the standard Zesty Paws Calming Chews. Zesty Paws Calming Chews for Dogs are a good budget option, providing similar benefits to the standard Zesty Paws Calming Chews at a lower price.
WOOF Pupsicle Refill Pops for Calming $19.99
Best balance of effectiveness and affordability
WOOF Pupsicle Refill Pops for Calming provides a long-lasting calming effect and mental stimulation at $19.99. Owners report significant stress relief, especially during noisy situations. The tradeoff is that it requires freezing and may not suit dogs that don't engage with frozen treats.
Check price on Amazon
Zesty Paws Calming Chews $29.72
Effective calming chews with positive owner feedback
Zesty Paws Calming Chews provide relaxation and stress relief at $29.72. Owners note varied effectiveness, but many report positive results. The tradeoff is the higher cost and potential for broken treats.
Check price on Amazon
Zesty Paws Calming Chews for Dogs $30.57
Affordable calming chews with good owner reviews
Zesty Paws Calming Chews for Dogs provide similar benefits to the standard Zesty Paws Calming Chews at $30.57. Owners report positive effects, though some note varying effectiveness. The tradeoff is the slightly higher price compared to the standard chews.
Check price on AmazonThe field, ranked
- WOOF Pupsicle Refill Pops for Calming Best for effectiveness and affordability 9.0/10 $19.99 Amazon
- Zesty Paws Calming Chews Good for varied effectiveness and positive feedback 8.0/10 $29.72 Amazon
- Zesty Paws Calming Chews for Dogs Decent for budget-friendly calming chews 7.0/10 $30.57 Amazon
- Pro Plan Calming Care Expensive with mixed results 6.0/10 $33.99 Amazon
- Zesty Paws Vet Strength Calming Chews for Dogs Expensive with no significant advantages 5.0/10 $49.97 Amazon
Where the differences show up in daily use
Owners of WOOF Pupsicle Refill Pops for Calming report that their dogs remain calm for over 20 minutes after consuming the treat, making it suitable for situations like renovations or thunderstorms. In contrast, Zesty Paws Calming Chews are chewable and can be given directly, which some owners find more convenient. However, the effectiveness of Zesty Paws varies among dogs, with some reporting significant calming effects and others noting little to no change.
Who should buy which
WOOF Pupsicle Refill Pops for Calming is best for owners looking for an affordable, long-lasting calming solution that requires freezing. Zesty Paws Calming Chews are suitable for owners who prefer chewable treats and are willing to pay a slightly higher price for potentially stronger calming effects. Pro Plan Calming Care is best for those who prioritize veterinary recommendations and are willing to invest in a more expensive option despite mixed results.
What owners complain about after buying
Some owners of Pro Plan Calming Care express frustration over the high cost and the time required to see results. There is also skepticism about the lack of cat-specific studies supporting the product. Owners of Zesty Paws Calming Chews occasionally report broken treats, which can be inconvenient. Additionally, some owners note varying effectiveness among different dogs, which can be disappointing for those expecting consistent results.
The also-rans
Pro Plan Calming Care, despite being veterinary recommended, loses out due to its high cost and mixed results. Zesty Paws Vet Strength Calming Chews, while offering a stronger formulation, lack significant advantages over the standard Zesty Paws Calming Chews, making them a less attractive option at a higher price.