The Best Disposable Paper Plates
We reviewed eight top-rated disposable paper plates, based on 400,000 owner ratings and detailed specs. The Amazon Basics Everyday Paper Plates are our top pick for their unbeatable value and durability.
Updated
The bottom line
The Amazon Basics Everyday Paper Plates (B0C2D1ZH9M) are our top pick for disposable paper plates. With a 200-count pack, these plates provide long-lasting supply at an affordable price point. Owners rate them 9.4 out of 10 from 60,058 ratings, praising their durability, cost-effectiveness, and convenience. The closest alternative is the Dixie Medium Paper Plates (B0748J34WZ), which offer similar durability and microwave safety but come in a smaller 90-count pack. For a budget option, the Amazon Basics Disposable Paper Plates (B0C2CY22B8) provide good value with a 100-count pack, though they are slightly smaller and may not hold up as well with very wet foods in the microwave.
Amazon Basics Everyday Paper Plates $11.12
Best value and durability
The Amazon Basics Everyday Paper Plates come in a 200-count pack for $11.12, providing long-lasting supply and affordability. Owners rate them 9.4 out of 10 from 60,058 ratings, highlighting their durability and cost-effectiveness. The tradeoff is that they are smaller than standard dinner plates.
Check price on Amazon
Dixie Medium Paper Plates $5.89
Strong and microwave-safe
The Dixie Medium Paper Plates are two times stronger than leading comparable store brand plates and are microwave-safe. They come in a 90-count pack for $5.89, with owners rating them 9.6 out of 10 from 67,160 ratings. The tradeoff is the smaller pack size compared to the top pick.
Check price on Amazon
Amazon Basics Disposable Paper Plates $5.97
Affordable and durable
The Amazon Basics Disposable Paper Plates come in a 100-count pack for $5.97, with owners rating them 9.4 out of 10 from 60,482 ratings. They are durable and microwave-safe but may not hold up as well with very wet foods in the microwave.
Check price on AmazonThe field, ranked
- Amazon Basics Everyday Paper Plates Best value and durability 9.0/10 $11.12 Amazon
- Dixie Medium Paper Plates Strong and microwave-safe 8.5/10 $5.89 Amazon
- Amazon Basics Disposable Paper Plates Affordable and durable 8.0/10 $5.97 Amazon
- Dixie Disposable Large Paper Plates Large and durable 8.0/10 $5.79 Amazon
- Dixie Paper Plates Large and versatile 8.0/10 $24.91 Amazon
- Dixie Large Paper Plates Large and strong 8.0/10 $57.92 Amazon
- Dixie Ultra Large Paper Plates Ultra-large and durable 8.0/10 $19.62 Amazon
- Dixie Ultra Large Paper Plates Ultra-large and sturdy 8.0/10 $6.49 Amazon
Where the differences show up in daily use
The Amazon Basics Everyday Paper Plates (B0C2D1ZH9M) have a large pack size and affordability, making them suitable for frequent use. Owners appreciate their durability and convenience, with many noting that the 200-count pack lasts a long time even with daily use. The Dixie Medium Paper Plates (B0748J34WZ) are praised for their strength and microwave safety, though some users find them a bit small for certain meals. The Amazon Basics Disposable Paper Plates (B0C2CY22B8) provide good value with a 100-count pack, but may not hold up as well with very wet foods in the microwave.
Who should buy which
For those who need a large supply of durable paper plates at an affordable price, the Amazon Basics Everyday Paper Plates (B0C2D1ZH9M) are the best choice. If you prioritize strength and microwave safety, the Dixie Medium Paper Plates (B0748J34WZ) are a good option. For a budget-friendly solution, the Amazon Basics Disposable Paper Plates (B0C2CY22B8) provide good value, though they may not be as durable with very wet foods.
What owners complain about after buying
A recurring complaint among owners is that some plates may not hold up as well with very wet foods in the microwave, particularly the Amazon Basics Disposable Paper Plates (B0C2CY22B8). Additionally, some users find the plates a bit small for certain meals, especially with the Dixie Medium Paper Plates (B0748J34WZ).
The also-rans
The Dixie Large Paper Plates (B074PXT678) and Dixie Paper Plates (B0F63C3W9X) are strong contenders but lose out due to smaller pack sizes and slightly higher prices. The Dixie Ultra Large Paper Plates (B099BWGZBP) and Dixie Ultra Large Paper Plates (B00J3IPS5W) offer larger sizes but come at a higher cost, making them less attractive for frequent use.