The Best Bully Stick Dog Treats
We compared eight bully sticks from Natural Farm, based on owner ratings, reviews, and specs. The top pick is the Natural Farm Bully Sticks (B07NXW7LP2) for its high quality and value.
Updated
The bottom line
The Natural Farm Bully Sticks (B07NXW7LP2) are our top pick for bully sticks. With an average owner rating of 9/10 from 15,532 ratings, these sticks are praised for their dental benefits, long-lasting nature, and odor-free formula. The runner-up is the Natural Farm Odor-Free Bully Sticks (B0CQMHRBZW), which offer similar quality at a slightly higher price. For budget-conscious buyers, the Natural Farm Bully Sticks (B08XY6JJTN) are a good option at $17.99 for a 2-stick pack, though they are shorter and fewer in number.
Natural Farm Bully Sticks $59.99
Best quality and value bully sticks
Natural Farm Bully Sticks (B07NXW7LP2) are made from 100% grass-fed beef, are odor-free, and help with dental care. With an average owner rating of 9/10 from 15,532 ratings, these sticks are a hit among dog owners. Priced at $59.99 for a 12-pack, they offer great value. The tradeoff is the higher price, but the quality and durability make it worth it for most dog owners.
Check price on Amazon
Natural Farm Odor-Free Bully Sticks $49.99
High-quality, odor-free bully sticks
Natural Farm Odor-Free Bully Sticks (B0CQMHRBZW) are praised for their minimal odor and consistent quality. With an average owner rating of 8.8/10 from 7,619 ratings, these sticks are a solid choice. Priced at $49.99 for a 16oz package, they are slightly more expensive but offer similar quality to the top pick. The tradeoff is the higher price, but the odor-free feature may be worth it for some owners.
Check price on Amazon
Bully Sticks $17.99
Affordable bully sticks with good reviews
Natural Farm Bully Sticks (B08XY6JJTN) offer a budget-friendly option at $17.99 for a 2-stick pack. With an average owner rating of 8.6/10 from 6,990 ratings, these sticks are a good choice for those looking to save money. The tradeoff is the shorter length and fewer sticks per pack, but the quality is still high.
Check price on AmazonThe field, ranked
- Natural Farm Bully Sticks Best quality, value, and durability. 10.0/10 $59.99 Amazon
- Natural Farm Odor-Free Bully Sticks High-quality, odor-free, but slightly more expensive. 9.0/10 $49.99 Amazon
- Bully Sticks Affordable with good quality, but fewer and shorter sticks. 8.0/10 $17.99 Amazon
- Bully Sticks High-quality, consistent, but expensive. 8.0/10 $59.99 Amazon
- Natural Farm Bully Sticks Good for medium chewers, but may not last long for heavy chewers. 7.0/10 $39.99 Amazon
- Bully Sticks Good for small dogs, but more expensive per stick. 7.0/10 $29.74 Amazon
- Collagen Chews, Bully Sticks, Dog Treats Long-lasting, but more expensive and fewer reviews. 6.0/10 $43.99 Amazon
- Natural Farm Collagen Sticks Dog Chews Good alternative to rawhide, but more expensive and fewer reviews. 6.0/10 $14.99 Amazon
Who should buy which
For those looking for the best quality and value, the Natural Farm Bully Sticks (B07NXW7LP2) are the top pick. If odor is a concern, the Natural Farm Odor-Free Bully Sticks (B0CQMHRBZW) are a great choice. Budget-conscious buyers should consider the Natural Farm Bully Sticks (B08XY6JJTN), though they are shorter and fewer in number.
What owners complain about
Some owners have complained about the odor of certain bully sticks, particularly the Natural Farm Bully Sticks (B07NXW7LP2) and (B089QXLCPX). However, these complaints are in the minority, and many owners have praised the minimal odor of the Natural Farm Odor-Free Bully Sticks (B0CQMHRBZW).
The also-rans
The Natural Farm Collagen Chews (B08PNMBYPY) and Natural Farm Collagen Sticks (B095J3PQ7K) did not make the top picks due to fewer reviews and higher prices. The Natural Farm Bully Sticks (B0CQMFMGVB) and (B07LB74PPJ) are good options but may not be the best choice for heavy chewers or those looking for the longest-lasting sticks.